Looks like Emma and William are siblings if this census is a link? 1880 Corwin, Logan, IL Abram SHAY, 56, IN, IN, IN, Farmer Wife, Laurinda, 56, VA, VA, VA, Keeping House Son, James K, Widowed, 35, IL, IN, VA, Farm Labor Son, John L, 25, IL, IN, VA, Farm Labor Dau, Harriett E., Single, 21, IL, IN, VA Son, William T, 19, IL, IN, VA, Farm Labor Son, Albert J., 15, IL, IN, VA, At School Dau, Emma A, 10, IL, IN, VA, At School GSon, Samuel A. Shay, 14, IL, IL, IL, At School GDau, Sarah E. Shay, 10, IL, IL, IL, At School Dau, Nancy E. Hudlow, 17, IL, IN, VA GDau, Annie A. Hudlow, 8, IL, IN, IL, At School IL Marriage Index: Nancy E Shay, m. James D. Hudlow, 8 Aug 1872, Mason, Co, IL Annie A. Hudlow, m. Columbus B. Snyder, 7 Sep 1891, Sangamon Emma W Shay, m. Solomon Morris, 30 Oct 1884, Logan (W should read A) Nancy E Jones, m. Willia F Shay, 10 Feb 1886, Logan (should read William)