Hi Donna, I see you're researching the Rich and Musgraves families. I assume that is Warren Rich and Sarah Musgrave. Their son Joseph married Mary Ann Dugan in 1864. She was a dau. of James Harvey Dugan (1820-1890) and Mary Emiline Barnett. Joseph and Mary Ann Rich had two children that I know of: Ella (b. 1868) and William (b. 1870). Richard Dugan