Thanks to all who have responded to my querry. I now have more questions than answers, but what's new? This is what I know about the line I am trying to figure out: David HILTON [b. ME] m. Betsy [ca. 1796 ME -aft 1880] ch. Betsy Ann HILTON [1830 OH -1886] m. Stephen CALL [1824 NY -1893] David HILTON [1827 OH -1896] m. Sarah Ann BISHOP [1831OH -1903] ch. Cyrus H. HILTON [1853-1926] m. Sarah Ann FOXWORTHY [1855-1926 / d/o Joseph FOXWORTHY & Mary Jane STRODE]] John Wesley HILTON [1862-1898] Jesse HILTON [ca. 1866-?] Martin Luther HILTON [1867-1935] m. Mabel ? Betsy HILTON appears w/ Stephen CALL household in 1880 age 86 b. ME The Sarah BISHOP who appears in the 1850 census w/ Spencer COOPER household is definitely the right age for the Sarah Ann who married David HILTON in 1851. Seth HILTON could certainly be a relative of the Davids. But I'm not sure at this point who fits where. It does now look like Sarah BISHOP is possibly not in my line, but that, too, is uncertain. Gee, I'm confused. Carol