Sorry folks, I had the information at my finger-tips and didn't realize it. Nancy Ellen Tuttle m. Porter Threlkeld, about 1887 per [Source: Wm. Tuttle, fellow researcher, via another researcher. :)] I apologize if I caused anyone some additonal research to figure it out!! Here is an outline for Porter: Descendants of Porter Threlkeld, Sr. [3 generations] 23 Porter Threlkeld, Sr. 1850 - .... +Nancy Ellen Tuttle 1872 - .. 24 Bonnie Threlkeld 1891 - ........ +Vera Lush ...... 25 Dorothy Threlkeld 1920 - .. 24 Porter Threlkeld, Jr. Nancy is the granddau. of Benjamin Tuttle & Gatsey Fox [or Legget]: Descendants of Benjamin Tuttle [3 generations] 23 Benjamin Tuttle 1790 - .... +Gatsey Fox_or_Legget? 1791 - 1866 .. 24 Abraham Tuttle .. 24 Lewis Tuttle 1822 - ........ +Ellen/Angeline Clark 1821 - ...... 25 Laban C. Tuttle 1860 - .. 24 Talitha Tuttle .. 24 William Stanley Tuttle 1821 - 1902 ........ +Mary Terry 1826 - 1859 ...... 25 Harvey Abram Tuttle 1843 - ............ +Louisa Benson ...... 25 Willaim Erwin Tuttle 1845 - 1902 ...... 25 John Lewis Tuttle 1850 - 1905 ...... 25 Sarah Louisa Tuttle 1851 - ............ +Joseph O. Boyle 1851 - ...... 25 Daniel Columbus Tuttle 1854 - ............ +Huldah Gatten 1855 - ...... 25 Hugh Elanzo Tuttle 1856 - ...... 25 Henry Clay Tuttle 1858 - .. *2nd Wife of William Stanley Tuttle: ........ +Sarah A. Bidlake 1844 - ...... 25 Clara Tuttle 1863 - ............ +James Brown? 1840 - .. *3rd Wife of William Stanley Tuttle: ........ +Margaret Brown 1830 - 1882 ...... 25 Henry C. Tuttle 1858 - ...... 25 Mary Jane Tuttle 1867 - ...... 25 Florence Ann Tuttle 1869 - ...... 25 Alexander Tuttle 1869 - 1870 ...... 25 Nancy Ellen Tuttle 1872 - ............ +Porter Threlkeld, Sr. 1850 - ...... 25 Noah Tuttle 1875 - .. *4th Wife of William Stanley Tuttle: ........ +Ellen Elizabeth Rheseker Gallagher 1847 - 1916 ...... 25 Clarence Tuttle 1885 - ...... 25 Maggie Tuttle 1890 - ............ +Grover Cleveland "Dick" Coles - 1922 ...... 25 Infant Tuttle 1892 - 1892 ...... 25 Lucinda "Lou" Tuttle 1893 - ............ +William Forten - 1957 .. 24 Rebecca Tuttle 1821 - .. 24 Guilford Tuttle 1829 - ........ +Angeline I. _____ 1824 - ...... 25 Harriet M. Tuttle 1855 - ............ +JOHN W. OLDFIELD 1849 - ...... 25 Ellen W./V. Tuttle 1856 - ...... 25 Florinda Tuttle 1858 - ...... 25 Winfield Tuttle 1861 - ...... 25 Laura I. Tuttle 1867 - .. 24 Noah Tuttle, Sr. 1828 - 1901 ........ +Barbara Teas/Tess/Tease 1839 - 1871 ...... 25 Gatsey Tuttle ...... 25 Rachel Tuttle ...... 25 William Tuttle ...... 25 Joseph Tuttle ...... 25 Grant Tuttle ...... 25 Martha Tuttle ...... 25 Charles Tuttle ...... 25 Noah Tuttle, Jr. 1864 - 1864 .. *2nd Wife of Noah Tuttle, Sr.: ........ +Margery Williams 1853 - 1923 ...... 25 Rachel Tuttle ...... 25 Bertha Tuttle ...... 25 Amanda Tuttle 1891 - ............ +Arthur Johnson 1887 - ...... 25 Ethel Tuttle ...... 25 Armour Tuttle 1894 - 1895 ...... 25 Guilford G. Tuttle 1896 - 1974 ............ +Augusta Shreck 1895 - 1958 ...... 25 Lydia Tuttle 1888 - 1963 ............ +John Guy Davis 1885 - .. 24 Marinda Tuttle Happy Hunting, Mary Beth