This is a Message Board Post that is gatewayed to this mailing list. Classification: Query Message Board URL: http://boards.ancestry.com/mbexec/msg/rw/Tk.2ADE/90.337.340.1 Message Board Post: Hello........I believe that I made a mistake with Marie May's name when I first wrote. My father's name was Raymond Goettel Hirth. I believe now that Marie was a Goettel, not a Hirth. I know of only one daughter that Marie and Frank had. She died fairly young, but not before she went to school and became an attorney. She went into business with her father, Frank. Frank died of tuberculosis, and the daughter died fairly soon after. Marie, known by the family as Aunt Mill, Mill or Millie, always kept a picture of this young woman in her living room. I saw it in 1934 when we spent the summer with her. She lived alone at that time and did until she hurt her back and was forced to enter a nursing home of some kind. The name Jenette is a mystery for me. It's certainly possible that Frank and Marie had a child that I never heard of. If you find out anything more please let me know. Thanks for writing........Mary Rae