Hi, For what it's worth...I have xeroxed the index section (Holmes only from Johanna thru Zeruiah) from the book Vital Records of Plymouth MA to the Year 1850 by Lee D. van Antwerp, by Picton Press, and find many, many HOLMES listed. I will share what names are mentioned and page number(s) if that will help anyone. There is no Shadrack Holmes for the person looking for him. Ruth [email protected]