I found this Charles living in Wayne Co, NY in 1870.. I have the image if you would like it Hope it helps, Cyd Rawls: NY WAYNE  SODUS  1870 Series: M593  Roll: 1113   Page: 475   GULICK  AMOS   50  M  W  b. NY  GULICK MARY 44 F b. NY GULICK CHARLES 21 M b.NY