Hi Valerie, Your question caught my eye as my sister-in-law's maiden name is Edwards, but I think her branch is different from yours. Arnold's VR of RI show a Peleg Edwards born to Christopher and Phebe on 3 Sept 1741 in Westerly, RI and his marriage to Margaret King on 15 Aug 1770 in West Greenwich. I know you said your Peleg was born in 1755 but if that is correct he would have been only 15 when he married Margaret. Is it possible he is the one born in 1741? That would seem to make a bit more sense. Good luck, Donna in RI