On 06-Sep-17 7:22 PM, Paulo Canedo wrote: > Judith's paternity is not controversial. The Life of Walteof affirms it was Lambert. See http://sbaldw.home.mindspring.com/hproject/prov/rober000.htm. This is the earliest source stating that Lambert was Judith's father - it is a 13th-century work following Orderic and containing errors. The controversy is real, based on the unreliability of the source and its derivatives and the problem that Judith was not Lambert's heiress. Peter Stewart