On 2016-06-30 03:30:15 +0000, Peter Stewart via said: > There is a misunderstanding somewhere in this: Baudouin who was killed > at Montauban in 1214 was definitely a brother of Raimond of Toulouse > whose parents were Raimond of Toulouse (numbering these men now is > practically worthless) and Constance of France. Whether Baudouin was > Raimond's full-brother or a paternal half-brother is less definite (he > was certainly not a maternal half-brother). > > However, it is highly questionable that Baudouin married Alix of > Lautrec, and even more so that they had any offspring. > > Philippe Zalmen Ben-Nathan in *Annales du Midi* 114 (2002) cogently > proposed that the brothers Bertrand I and Sicard VI of Lautrec were > actually sons of Frotard III, and that Alix may have been the latter's > sister with no known posterity from a possible marriage to Baudouin of > Toulouse. You can read or download his article here (and copy-paste > from it into an online French-English translator), > http://www.persee.fr/doc/anami_0003-4398_2002_num_114_239_2777. Thank you for this. I did in fact read Google Translate's approximation of the article, and a subsequent search-engine trawl through the world of Francophone medieval genealogy makes it clear that this model is now the one predominantly accepted there. -- Patrick Nielsen Hayden pnh@panix.com about.me/patricknh http://nielsenhayden.com/genealogy-tng/index.php