Em sexta-feira, 1 de julho de 2016 00:57:44 UTC+1, Peter Stewart via escreveu: > On 30/06/2016 11:50 PM, pauloricardocanedo2 via wrote: > > Well even if Ed Mann uses some false connections in some of his works it doesn´t mean the other works he does are wrong. > > > > > > Of course it doesn't - however, it does mean that the work is most > probably no better than other bunglers could do for themselves. > > This is the same pitiful excuse that has been made here for depending on > Medieval Lands. > > The facile habit of using readily-accessible stashes of data causes many > an amateur in medieval genealogy to waste time and effort. It means that > one busy ignoramus exerts an influence in this field that is out of all > proportion to the skill and sense brought to it. > > Self-indulgent clinging to trust in self-evident charlatans is currently > disgracing two of the world's greatest nations. It doesn't have to > disfigure SGM discussions as well. > > Peter Stewart I was wrong, the genealogist who uses the connection Millicent de Rethel-William de Camville isn´t Ed Mann it is Leo Van de Pas.