Carol, Thank you for all your work. The only difference that I can see that I know of is the order of Elzys wives. Mattie Belle Martin was the third wife. Also, Dads name was actually Robbie instead of Robert. The "annette" age 3 listed in the 1930 census with Elzy and Mattie is the daughter of Ethel A, Elzy and Matties daughter Once again, Thanks! bobbie