Gail, My reference to error in Huxford pertained to the listing of Lucy Pickren to Huxford's section on the Elijah Pickren family and the John Pickren family. He lists a Lucy Pickren b. 1838 to Elijah Pickren who married Catherine Girtman (this Elijah is the son of the John Pickren family listed in POWG. This Elijah Pickren never had a dau. named Lucy at any time. So other researchers at later times when finding a Lucy Pickren who m. Moses J. Kirkland mistakenly assumed that this Lucy was the dau. of Elijah and Catherine (Girtman) Pickren. And so the erroneous "fact" kept spreading and spreading. I'll ask other Kirkland researchers to answer all the questions about the descendants of the Kirkland marriages. Paula