In a message dated 4/17/01 7:49:51 PM Eastern Daylight Time, [email protected] writes: << Subj: duttons Date: 4/17/01 7:49:51 PM Eastern Daylight Time From: [email protected] (John Dolan) To: [email protected] (al) << AL, ARE YOU SAYING THAT ANDREW AND JOSEPH ARE ONE PERSON , JOHN >> John, you asked a very good question. I am glad you asked. I thought I had the correct answer but then as I looked back over my information and resources I realized they are the not the same person and my earlier conclusion was incorrect. Andrew died young after two possible marriages. His second wife Sarah Margaret Williams (I believe at this point) married Joseph Dutton - Andrew's brother. I think what is confusing is that Joseph Dutton is buried next to Sarah Williams Dutton at New Hope Church Cemetery in Bulloch County, GA -- while marriage records in Bulloch County show Sarah Williams married Andrew Dutton. I made a mistake in assuming they were the same person. Since you raised the question I have reviewed my information with the sources I have and have revised my "Draft" of the Dutton family. There is still so much that is confusing and missing in this family. I believe that many Dutton children were reared in households of other relatives but the early census records do not show their true relationship. Below is the latest DRAFT of what I believe the early Dutton family looked like. I hope others working on this family will offer corrections and new information. The history of this family is far from complete. If you copied the former information I posted earlier into your records please make the necessary changes in PENCIL -- this too will most likely change with the next email and shared information. I have included my references for anyone to check out. Sincerely, Alfred Chassereau Descendants of Henry Dutton, (JP) Justice of the Peace/Bulloch County Generation No. 1 1. Henry1 Dutton, JP 1,2,3 was born March 1789 in Massachusetts?, and died June 27, 1851 in Bulloch County, Georgia. He married (1) Mary Ann Wilson4 January 21, 1818 in Bulloch County, Georgia5, daughter of Andrew Wilson and Elizabeth ???. She was born January 1800 in North Carolina, and died February 10, 1843 in Bulloch County, Georgia. He married (2) Ann Theresa Cox6 February 06, 1845 in Bulloch County, Georgia, daughter of Spencer Cox and Sarah Hickman. She was born November 14, 1800 in Bryan County, Georgia, and died October 02, 1880 in Bryan County, Georgia. Children of Henry Dutton and Mary Wilson are: + 2 i. Elizabeth2 Dutton, born Abt. 1820 in Bulloch County, Georgia. + 3 ii. Samuel Dutton, born Abt. 1821 in Bulloch County, Georgia; died in Bulloch County, Georgia. + 4 iii. Zedakiah E. Dutton, CSA, born November 28, 1822 in Bulloch County, Georgia; died April 29, 1887 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 5 iv. James Dutton7, born Abt. 1824 in Bulloch County, Georgia. + 6 v. Joseph Dutton, Sr., born August 01, 1825 in Bulloch County, Georgia; died August 06 in Bulloch County, Georgia. + 7 vi. Andrew Dutton, born Abt. 1829 in Bulloch County, Georgia; died Bef. 1870 in Bulloch County, Georgia. + 8 vii. William H. Dutton, CSA, born Abt. 1831 in Bulloch County, Georgia; died November 13, 1875 in Bulloch County, Georgia. + 9 viii. Henrietta M. Dutton, born Abt. 1832 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 10 ix. Mary E. Dutton8, born August 01, 1834 in Bulloch County, Georgia; died May 1873 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 11 x. John Wesley Dutton, CSA, born Abt. 1837 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 12 xi. Overton Dutton9,10, born March 19, 1840 in Bulloch County, Georgia; died February 05, 1902 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 13 xii. Martha Dutton11, born January 28, 1842 in Bulloch County, Georgia; died June 25, 1851 in Bulloch County, Georgia. Generation No. 2 2. Elizabeth2 Dutton (Henry1)12,13 was born Abt. 1820 in Bulloch County, Georgia. She married Isham (Hagin) Hagan14 January 11, 1844 in Bulloch County, Georgia14, son of ??? Hagan and Ellena ???. He was born Abt. 1818 in Bulloch County, Georgia. Children of Elizabeth Dutton and Isham Hagan are: 14 i. Henry3 Hagan15, born Abt. 1846. 15 ii. Morgan Hagan15,16, born Abt. 1847 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 16 iii. Leonard Hagan17, born Abt. 1849 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 17 iv. Victoria Hagan17, born Abt. 1852 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 18 v. Caroline Hagan17, born Abt. 1855. 19 vi. Mitchell Hagan17, born Abt. 1857 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 3. Samuel2 Dutton (Henry1)18 was born Abt. 1821 in Bulloch County, Georgia, and died in Bulloch County, Georgia. He married Sarah (Hagin) Hagan August 24, 1845 in Bulloch County, Georgia19, daughter of Absolom Hagan and Tabitha Sheppard. She was born Abt. 1819 in Bulloch County, Georgia, and died Bet. 1854 - 1860 in Bulloch County, Georgia. Children of Samuel Dutton and Sarah Hagan are: + 20 i. Thomas Absalom3 Dutton, Sr., CSA, born June 28, 1846 in Effingham County, Georgia?; died August 30, 1875 in Marlow, Effingham County, Georgia. 21 ii. Sarah Ann Dutton20, born April 09, 1848 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 22 iii. Elizabeth Dutton21, born August 23, 1850 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 23 iv. Henrietta Dutton21,22,23, born January 25, 1853 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 24 v. Harriet O. Dutton24,25, born Abt. 1854 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 4. Zedakiah E.2 Dutton, CSA (Henry1)26 was born November 28, 1822 in Bulloch County, Georgia, and died April 29, 1887 in Bulloch County, Georgia. He married (1) Martha (Hagins) Hagan January 01, 1851 in Bulloch County, Georgia27, daughter of Absolom Hagan and Tabitha Sheppard. She was born Abt. 1830 in Bulloch County, Georgia, and died Bet. 1853 - 1863. He married (2) Jane (Jannie) Chitty 28 October 11, 1863 in Bulloch County, Georgia, daughter of William Chitty and Cynthia ???. She was born February 09, 1841 in South Carolina, and died January 06, 1892 in Bulloch County, Georgia. Child of Zedakiah Dutton and Martha Hagan is: 25 i. Zenobia3 Dutton29, born January 01, 1853 in Bulloch County, Georgia. Children of Zedakiah Dutton and Jane Chitty are: + 26 i. Frances (Fanny) M.3 Dutton, born Abt. 1866 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 27 ii. William Dutton, born Abt. 1868. 28 iii. Thomas M. Dutton, born Abt. 1870. 29 iv. Lilla P. Dutton, born Abt. 1872 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 30 v. Curtis W. Dutton, born Abt. 1878. 31 vi. James E. Dutton, born April 1879. 6. Joseph2 Dutton, Sr. (Henry1)30,31 was born August 01, 1825 in Bulloch County, Georgia, and died August 06 in Bulloch County, Georgia. He married (1) Nancy Williams32,33 Abt. 1849 in Bulloch County, Georgia, daughter of Robert Williams and Martha Gay. She was born January 03, 1834 in Bulloch County, Georgia, and died August 17, 1864 in Bulloch County, Georgia. He married (2) Sarah ??? Aft. 1864 in Bulloch County, Georgia. She was born Abt. 1837. Children of Joseph Dutton and Nancy Williams are: + 32 i. Laura A.3 Dutton, born August 02, 1853 in Bulloch County, Georgia; died March 06, 1935 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 33 ii. Mary J. Dutton34, born June 21, 1855 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 34 iii. Joseph H. Dutton, Jr.35, born Abt. 1856 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 35 iv. Caroline (Cornelia?) Dutton35, born Abt. 1858 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 36 v. Andrew D. Dutton35, born Abt. 1859 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 37 vi. William Dutton36, born Abt. 1860. 7. Andrew2 Dutton (Henry1)37,38 was born Abt. 1829 in Bulloch County, Georgia, and died Bef. 1870 in Bulloch County, Georgia. He married (1) ???. She died Bef. 1857 in Bulloch County, Georgia. He married (2) Sarah Martha Williams39,40 November 17, 1857 in Bulloch County, Georgia41, daughter of Robert Williams and Martha Gay. She was born May 15, 1837 in Bulloch County, Georgia, and died May 28, 1897 in Bulloch County, Georgia. Children of Andrew Dutton and ??? are: + 38 i. John C.3 Dutton, born March 01, 1852 in Bulloch County, Georgia; died in Bulloch County, Georgia. 39 ii. Nancy J. Dutton42, born March 09, 1853 in Bulloch County, Georgia. Children of Andrew Dutton and Sarah Williams are: 40 i. Mary3 Dutton43, born Abt. 1859 in Bulloch County, Georgia; died Bef. 1870 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 41 ii. William A. Dutton44, born Abt. 1861 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 42 iii. Nancy Ada Dutton44, born Abt. 1862 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 43 iv. Martha Dutton44, born Abt. 1864 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 44 v. John W. Dutton, born Abt. 1867 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 45 vi. Jennett Dutton, born Abt. 1869 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 46 vii. Emma A. Dutton, born Abt. 1870 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 47 viii. Amanda Dutton, born Abt. 1871 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 48 ix. Jane R. Dutton, born Abt. 1873 in Bulloch County, Georgia. + 49 x. Ida J. Dutton, born November 14, 1874 in Bulloch County, Georgia; died September 01, 1949 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 8. William H.2 Dutton, CSA (Henry1)44 was born Abt. 1831 in Bulloch County, Georgia, and died November 13, 1875 in Bulloch County, Georgia. He married Mary ???44. She was born Abt. 1836. Children of William Dutton and Mary ??? are: 50 i. Henrietta3 Dutton44, born Abt. 1853 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 51 ii. Harriet O. Dutton44, born Abt. 1855 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 9. Henrietta M.2 Dutton (Henry1)45,46 was born Abt. 1832 in Bulloch County, Georgia. She married Robert R. Terrell47,48 March 09, 1848 in Bulloch County, Georgia48. He was born Abt. 1825 in Bulloch County, Georgia. Child of Henrietta Dutton and Robert Terrell is: 52 i. Thomas3 Terrell49, born Abt. 1850 in Bulloch County, Georgia. Generation No. 3 20. Thomas Absalom3 Dutton, Sr., CSA (Samuel2, Henry1)49 was born June 28, 1846 in Effingham County, Georgia?, and died August 30, 1875 in Marlow, Effingham County, Georgia. He married Eugenia Natalia Foy September 03, 1870 in Marriage application obtained in Bulloch County, Georgia50, daughter of George Foy and Rebecca Dasher. She was born November 18, 1848 in Egypt, Effingham County, Georgia, and died July 09, 1910 in Egypt, Effingham County, Georgia. Children of Thomas Dutton and Eugenia Foy are: 53 i. Infant Son4 Dutton, born in Egypt, Effingham County, Georgia; died in Egypt, Effingham County, Georgia. 54 ii. Sarah Ella Dutton, born August 05, 1872 in Egypt, Effingham County, Georgia; died September 13, 1882 in Egypt, Effingham County, Georgia. 55 iii. Thomas Absalom Dutton, Jr., born April 01, 1875 in Egypt, Effingham County, Georgia; died October 27, 1927 in Egypt, Effingham County, Georgia. He married Mattie Carroll Fryar September 15, 1897 in Magnolia, North Carolina; born November 19, 1874 in Duplin County, North Carolina; died October 06, 1909 in Egypt, Effingham County, Georgia. 26. Frances (Fanny) M.3 Dutton (Zedakiah E.2, Henry1) was born Abt. 1866 in Bulloch County, Georgia. She married Thaddus A. Newsome July 22, 1888 in Bulloch County, Georgia51. He was born in Bulloch County, Georgia. Children of Frances Dutton and Thaddus Newsome are: 56 i. Infant4 Newsome52, born September 19, 1897 in Bulloch County, Georgia; died May 06, 1898 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 57 ii. William F. Newsome52, born Abt. 1897 in Bulloch County, Georgia; died Abt. 1898 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 32. Laura A.3 Dutton (Joseph2, Henry1)52 was born August 02, 1853 in Bulloch County, Georgia, and died March 06, 1935 in Bulloch County, Georgia. She married Aaron Clarke52 April 24, 1873 in Bulloch County, Georgia53, son of Alexander Clarke and Frances ???. He was born February 18, 1850 in South Carolina or Bulloch County, Georgia, and died May 14, 1934 in Bulloch County, Georgia. Children of Laura Dutton and Aaron Clarke are: 58 i. Lula4 Clarke, born Abt. 1876 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 59 ii. Frances (Fannie) Clarke, born February 07, 1877 in Bulloch County, Georgia; died November 01, 1919 in Bulloch County, Georgia. She married ??? Miley. 38. John C.3 Dutton (Andrew2, Henry1)54,55 was born March 01, 1852 in Bulloch County, Georgia, and died in Bulloch County, Georgia. He married Sarah Ann Waters December 24, 1878 in Bulloch County, Georgia, daughter of Isaac Waters and Jane Barber. She was born December 1855 in Bulloch County, Georgia, and died January 09, 1931 in Jacksonville, Florida56. Children of John Dutton and Sarah Waters are: 60 i. William C.4 Dutton, born September 1879 in Bulloch County, Georgia. He married ???. 61 ii. Charles M. Dutton, born October 1882. 62 iii. George W. Dutton, born May 1884 in Bulloch County, Georgia. He married ???. 63 iv. Sarah M. (Mattie) Dutton, born April 1888 in Bulloch County, Georgia. She married (1) ??? Wainwright. She married (2) Walter S. Bates April 08, 1928; born in Jacksonville, Florida. 64 v. Martha M. Dutton, born March 1890. 49. Ida J.3 Dutton (Andrew2, Henry1)57 was born November 14, 1874 in Bulloch County, Georgia, and died September 01, 1949 in Bulloch County, Georgia. She married William Harrison Sharpe57 March 23, 1893 in Ray Mill, Bulloch County, Georgia58. He was born October 28, 1866 in Bulloch County, Georgia, and died February 13, 1940 in Bulloch County, Georgia. Children of Ida Dutton and William Sharpe are: 65 i. Robert Grady4 Sharpe59, born August 22, 1893 in Bulloch County, Georgia; died December 07, 1894 in Bulloch County, Georgia. 66 ii. Martha Kate Sharpe60, born in Bulloch County, Georgia; died in Bulloch County, Georgia. She married Hammond Dell Anderson61,62,63 in Bulloch County, Georgia; born January 17, 1889 in Bulloch County, Georgia; died September 26, 1973 in Bulloch County, Georgia. Endnotes 1. 1850 Bulloch County Census, page 4.. 2. Grave marker in New Hope Methodist Church Cemetery, Bulloch County, Georgia. 3. Bulloch County Genealogical Source Materials, Alvaretta K. Register, 1985, page 189. 4. Grave marker in New Hope Methodist Church Cemetery, Bulloch County, Georgia. 5. Bulloch County Genealogical Source Materials, Alvaretta K. Register, 1985, page 157 6. 1850 Bulloch County Census. 7. 1850 Bulloch County Census, page 2.. 8. Grave marker in New Hope Methodist Cemetery, Bulloch County, Georgia. 9. 1870 Bulloch County Census, page 65.. 10. Grave marker in New Hope Methodist Church Cemetery, Bulloch County, Georgia. 11. Grave marker in New Hope Methodist Cemetery, Bulloch County, Georgia. 12. Bulloch County Genealogical Source Material, Alvaretta Register, page 165.. 13. 1860 Bulloch County Census. 14. Bulloch County Genealogical Source Material, Alvaretta Register, page 165.. 15. 1860 Bulloch County Census. 16. 1850 Bulloch County Census. 17. 1860 Bulloch County Census. 18. 1850 Bulloch County Census, page 3.. 19. Bulloch County Genealogical Source Materials, Alvaretta K. Register, 1985, page 166 & 167. 20. 1850 Bulloch County Census. 21. 1860 Bulloch County Census. 22. 1870 Bulloch County Census. 23. Bulloch County Genealogical Source Materials, Alvaretta K. Register, 1985, page 394 & 395. 24. 1860 Bulloch County Census. 25. 1870 Bulloch County Census. 26. Grave marker in New Hope Methodist Cemetery, Bulloch County, Georgia. 27. Bulloch County Genealogical Source Materials, Alvaretta K. Register, 1985, page 170. 28. Grave marker in New Hope Methodist Cemetery, Bulloch County, Georgia. 29. Bulloch County Genealogical Source Materials, Alvaretta K. Register, 1985, page 394 & 395. 30. Grave marker in New Hope Methodist Cemetery, Bulloch County, Georgia. 31. 1860 Bulloch County Census. 32. Bulloch County Genealogical Sources, A. K. Register, 1985, Common School Funds, page 415.. 33. 1860 Bulloch County Census. 34. Bulloch County Genealogical Source Material, Alvaretta Register, page 394.. 35. 1860 Bulloch County Census. 36. 1880 Bulloch County Census. 37. 1850 Bulloch County Census. 38. 1860 Bulloch County Census. 39. Grave marker in New Hope Methodist Cemetery, Bulloch County, Georgia. 40. 1860 Bulloch County Census. 41. Bulloch County Genealogical Source Materials, Alvaretta K. Register, 1985, page 175. 42. Bulloch County Genealogical Source Material, Alvaretta Register, page 394.. 43. 1860 Bulloch County Census. 44. 1870 Bulloch County Census. 45. 1850 Bulloch County Census. 46. Bulloch County Genealogical Source Materials, Alvaretta K. Register, 1985, page 157. 47. 1850 Bulloch County Census. 48. Bulloch County Genealogical Source Materials, Alvaretta K. Register, 1985, page 157. 49. 1850 Bulloch County Census. 50. Bulloch County Georgia Genealogical Source Materials, A. K. Register, page 194.. 51. Bulloch County, Georgia Resource Material, Alverta K. Register, 1985, page 258.. 52. Grave marker in New Hope Methodist Cemetery, Bulloch County, Georgia. 53. Bulloch County Genealogical Source Material, Alvaretta Register, page 185.. 54. Bulloch County Genealogical Source Materials, Alvaretta K. Register, 1985, page 394 & 395. 55. 1880 Bulloch County Census, page 105; 1900 Bulloch County Cenus, page 133.. 56. Sarah A. Dutton Obituary, Statesboro Newspaper, January 15, 1931 issue.. 57. Gravemarker in Eastside Cemtery, Statesboro, Bulloch County, Georgia.. 58. Wedding Announcement, Statesboro Newspaper, March 30, 1893, issue.. 59. Gravemarker in Eastside Cemtery, Statesboro, Bulloch County, Georgia.. 60. Martha Kate Anderson Lamb Obituary, Statesboro Herald, December 26, 2. 61. Gravemarker in Eastside Cemtery, Statesboro, Bulloch County, Georgia.. 62. E. M. Anderson Obituary, Statesboro News, June 12, 1924, issue.. 63. Martha Kate Anderson Lamb Obituary, Statesboro Herald, December 26, 2.