I'm not positive we have a match but find striking similarities between your Hiram and the family members of Farley Fuller and Minerva. Farley Fuller was one of the founders of the town of Russia in Herkimer County, NY in 1792. He later moved to Ripley, Chataugua County NY in 1804, where he was living when he died in 1844. The Fullers were founding members of the Methodist Church at Ripley. Census records for Ripley in 1850 show a Hiram Fuller, although that is the only time I found that name. (This tidbit may not help, but my Palmer relatives were also living in Ripley for a time, and also moved to Ohio and Wisconsin, seemingly with the Elisha Fuller.) Known (or strongly suspected) children of Farley Fuller: Elisha 1811-1870 Luther b about 1800 George (1806-) Amos (1799-) Truman (1804-) Mary? (1802-1884) Noah or Alvah? (1800-1855) What is most interesting is that my ancestor, Elisha, moved from Ripley to Conneaut, Ashtabula County, OH where he married. They later moved to Grant County WI. You didn't mention counties for all the moves of Hiram, but I thought it might be worth looking for a connection.