Mara, Charlie, Jim - Please reply here <<french@rootsweb.com>> I am only getting part of your conversation. Three FRENCH GUYS (Group 6) submitted their DNA here: http://small-stuff.com/FRENCH/DNA/tree6.htm Mara, I provided Test # F12684. You wrote to Charlie <<<<<<<OK. Then it is old information to you. Are you the one who submitted the DNA Test #F13919? If so, the dates on the test below yours (F12684) seem to be incorrect and I'm wondering just how exact the genealogys. If accurate, that test would prove that Charts #1 and #2 are related. Perhaps I'll take the time to research that line more accurately. Mara >>>>>>> Charlie provided Test # F13919. Jim provided Test #F14781. I have proven my lineage back to WILLIAM OF BILLERICA. What have you seen on the chart that looks inaccurate? Jim's pedigree is solid. Charlie is and has been struggling with his. Thanks - Scott French > Whoever William French's (FFA Chart #2) father was, he had another > son, John French (FFA Chart #3). > Since Jim and I have a 24/25 y-chromosome allele marker match, we > have a reasonably recent common ancestor. Perhaps that ancestor is > Jacob French (b. 1553). Pedigrees here: http://small-stuff.com/ > FRENCH/DNA/tree6.htm > Are you a proven male descendant of either William or John? If you > are, there are thousands of reasons to order a DNA sample kit from > familytreedna (http://www.familytreedna.com/default.asp).