Just to satisfy my curiosity as to how things work, if Patricia submits an acceptable correction to the Baverstock entry, will all eleven Baverstock entries on that page be amended, or just the one for Cordelia? Barry Callaghan ----- Original Message ----- From: "Allan Raymond" <allan_raymond@btinternet.com> To: <FreeBMD-Admins-L@rootsweb.com> Sent: Wednesday, November 30, 2005 2:31 PM Subject: Re: {not a subscriber} Problems with Reporting Errors > Patricia > > The scan source used by our volunteer is somewhat unclear and transcribed > to the best of his/her > ability using the FreeBMD process for > showing unclear letters/characters. > > Using the information you supplied and searching for an entry Bav* in 1910 > Dec quarter I came up > with > > Bav[e_]rsto[c_]k,Cord[e_]lia E > > You would have been able to send the following correction. > > ************************************************************* > Surname: Baverstock > Given names: Cordelia E > > The source of their information has been given as: > FreeBMD Scan ACDB-01/A-J/1910M4-B-0056.tif. > ************************************************************* > > This provides all the information to enable a decision to be made on > whether the correction is valid > or not and for it be acted on. > > The process to report corrections will work if the instructions are > followed. > > In particular I reproduce the following from the Corrections Page: > > "It is NOT possible to apply a correction based upon Census, IGI, > Certificate, Family Bible, etc. > This is because names are recorded as they appear in the GRO Index". > > "Corrections MUST be based on evidence of THIS entry in the index. > Corrections based on the > reference of the other party to a marriage or of spelling of name used for > another event for the > same person are NOT valid" > > " When completing the source field, please just tell us, in as few words > as possible, where you > found the information. Lengthy explanations, or worse still spirited > advocacy supporting the > correction are unhelpful." > > You may wish to have another go at submitting a correction either taking > into account my comments or > those on the Corrections Page. > > Allan Raymond > > > > > > ----- Original Message ----- > From: "Patricia" <trishlovell@waitrose.com> > To: <FreeBMD-Admins-l@rootsweb.com> > Sent: 29 November 2005 14:52 > Subject: {not a subscriber} Problems with Reporting Errors > > > I tried to report that an error had been made in the index for Cordelia > E Baverstock's marriage in the December quarter of 1910. > > I tried to find her and came up with a 'not found'. Fortunately I knew > her husband, (Wallace) Beckingham and found him. > > When I looked for the page of entries I found that your transcriber had > experienced great difficulty in reading the entry for Cordelia. > > I tried to report it, filling in the missed letters, but your system > would not allow me to submit the report as it did not comply with your > criteria. > > Had I not known that Aunt Delia had become Mrs. Beckingham I would not > have got any further with my search for the date. > > What went wrong with my submission? Surely there is some flexibility > when it comes to filling in missed letters in a relative's name where > the transcriber has been unable to read the entry? > > I can appreciate that someone's family notes are not necessarily proof, > but I tried to give you the entry for her birth to substantiate my > correction March qtr 1877 Portsea Island 2b 612 but this was rejected. > > I find FreeBMD indispensable for my family history, but why has it > become so much more difficult to make reports to you? > > Regards > > Trish Lovell > > > > > > ==== FreeBMD-Admins Mailing List ==== > Need to get a fast answer to your transcribing problems? Go to the > Transcribers Knowledge Base at http://FreeBMD.RootsWeb.com/vol_faq.html > > ============================== > Search Family and Local Histories for stories about your family and the > areas they lived. Over 85 million names added in the last 12 months. > Learn more: http://www.ancestry.com/s13966/rd.ashx > >