Hi Dusti Seems like you and I are pretty stuck with our FINKs....:( we spoke a long time ago and I have not budged an inch with John Fink's history. I wish I could help you but anything is possible....but it sounds like your Jacob Fink might have been born more western PA thereby going to OH and winding up in IN whereby my John Fink I believe was born more eastern PA and wound up in NY. Good Luck and good to hear from you again Marie