I grew up in Clayton, New York. In fact, the house that Catherine Purcell Marshall built and raised her family in is the house I grew up in and now my brother owns it so his son makes the 5th generation living there. My Catherine (Cookie Grandma) was born June 30,1860 and died Jan 31, 1951. She married Louis Marshall. Her parents were Patrick Purcell and Elizabeth Ivey. Anything sound familiar? Becky