Dear Jim, I think that your four variant spelling for Apollos Fay are for the same person. The variants were Apollas Fay (1840); Apolos (1830) and Apolus (1850) and Appollos Fay (1860). This person lived in Bronson Township in Huron County, Oh. OPF gives the name as Apollos Fay (a fifth variant spelling). This Apollos Fay is OPF #977 on OPF, 1898: p. 85-86) He is known to have died in Norwalk, OH March 21. 1859. He married Lucy Hussington. Sincerely, Mary (FAY) Nelson 9