Morning all, >From the 1850 Parma, Cuyahoga County, Ohio Federal Census Dwelling 1543 Family 1673 Benajah FAY 70 M 6000 MA Rhoda 72 F Canada Jeremiah 28 M NY Eliza 17 F Ohio Lavina 11 F MA >From my previous email, looking at the big picture, it's highly unlikely Mary FAY(adopted daughter of Jeremiah FAY & Mary BRADLEY) was a daughter of Benajah FAY & Rhoda EDWARDS. The age for this Lavina may be wrong, as it's possible it may be Benajah's sister. This Eliza FAY is probably the one living with Mabel FAY HUMPHREY's family on the 1860 census.