So....if one of Richard Evans' SONS [Noah] married a Robinson [Elizabeth Dodd Robinson], does that count as the book saying that one of Richard's brothers-in-law was the Robinson who got killed by Indians? Note that Elizabeth Dodd Robinson was from Chillicothe... and there was a Joshua Robinson also from Chillicothe. Think this is it? See below Elizabeth and Joshua were bro and sis R ------------ William Robinson born Aug 7, 1764 ob Aug 8, 1822 buried in Union Meeting house Cem Ross Co, O. He & his family migrated to Ross Co, O near Chillicothe & later made a permanent settlement near Bloomingburg, Fayette Co, Ohio. Married 1 Sept 4, 1787 Jane Carson who died Dec 8, 1795 having had five children all probably born in Fayette Co, Pa. Married 2 Aug 29, 1797 Sally Conwell b June 6, 1772 ob Jany 12, 1845 & buried Bloomingburg, O, daughter of Capt Wm Conwell & wife Comfort Coulter of Fay Co, Pa. They had nine children. [children] Sally Robinson b July 29, 1788 married Robertson, Robison or Robinson Jane Robinson b May 1, 1790 married James Stewart Mary Finley Robinson Dec 25, 1791 married Gillespie 4* Rachel Robinson B Dec 3, 1793 married Adam Steele Elizabeth Dodd Robinson b Nov 1795 married Noah Evans Henry Kennedy Robinson b Aug 10, 1798 ob Aug 24, 1812 James Allen Robinson b Aug 31, 1800 drowned Aug 19, 1802 Comfort Robinson b June 10, 1802 married Mch 22, 1827 Oliver Morrison William M. Robinson b June 20, 1804 married June 29, 1824 Mary Crumpton Lydia Robinson b Mch 8, 1806 married July 26, 1825 Wm Mitchell James Kennedy Robinson b Apr 17, 1808 married Dec 20, 1832 to Ann Jane Morrison Joshua Campbell Robinson b Feby 3, 1810 married June 19, 1834 Eliza Ann Stitt Margaret Coulter Robinson b Nov 20, 1813 married Sally Ann Robinson b Apr 30, 1816 married Mch 22, 1848 Joel Carman Elam.

Noah and Elizabeth have the same birth dates. I believe that the Ayres book made a mistake.