Hi List, After being off list for awhile thought I would see if anyone can help with a brick wall of mine. Samuel SHACKLETON b.1814 at Bingley & Elizabeth SMITH b.1814 at Cullingworth were my g.g.grandparents,but I can't find a marriage anywhere for them. They had the following children; Ellen b.1835 at Dubb,Bingley-died 1850,Bingley. Martha b.1837 at Dubb.-died 1844,Bingley. William b.1838,Dubb-died 1873,Bingley(my g.grandfather).In 1851 census,William was with grandfather,William SMITH. Hannah b.1842,Dubb.-died 1858,Bingley. Mathew b.1843 at Dubb;married Sarah ?. Mary b.1846 at Dubb;marr Jonas NORMINGTON,1866 at Bingley. Any suggestions on how to find marriage? I have checked parish registers for Bingley but there is no sign,although there is a blank page on the filming of it about the right date. Thanks for reading, Joyce