Hello Margaret, I have checked the 1851 for Thornaby on Tees, known in 1851 as South Stockton. Charlie does not appear there. A Charles ROBINSON is noted as under, perhaps a possible pointer. Peter St Paul's Baptism 15 Jul 1866 ref No 1264. ROBINSON Charles. Parents Richard and Elizabeth 1881 census 4862 f 127 STAFFORD PLACE 23. ROBINSON Charles aged 14 Born THORNABY These two above entries a possible matching pair 1881 census 4863 f 35 GILMORE STREET 60 ROBINSON Charles aged 25 Born LAMBERHURST > > ______________________________