I am asking for suggestions of ways to identify, which of the two birth certificates below belongs to my great-grandfather CHARLES WARBURTON. He was born in Manchester but lived in Bolton, working as a shoemaker, from the mid 1890’s up to his death in 1922 (There, that keeps me ‘on subject’ for the Bolton list). 1) Charles Warburton. 18 Walter Street, Hulme. 10th July 1846. Father - Joseph Warburton: Mother - Elizabeth Street. 2) Charles Warburton. 62 Fleet Street, Manchester. 8th February 1847. Father - Joseph Warburton: Mother - Anne Lister. I have his death certificate, the 1881, 1891 and 1901 censuses, all of which confirm that he was born in Manchester between April 1846 and April 1847. The above certificates are the only two Charles Warburton’s born at the right time and place. I also have found MY Charles Warburton on the 1861 working as a shoemaker’s apprentice but unfortunately he was staying at his employers address and not with his parents. According to the census returns he was married but their's no record of this. I need to narrow down his date of birth. Barry Bain