Many thanks to Carol, Peter, Peter, Nick, David and Sheila for their help. I now have Esther CHARD and two daughters, now to find the boys ! Two possible burial grounds were mentioned, Hull City Cemetery on Heddon Road and Western General in Springbank for Esther ( died 1916 ) and her husband William ( died 1890 ) . I am on the prowl for MI's, does anyone know if these graveyards have been 'done' ? Regards Peter in Auckland NZ.