Hi Alison Cannot suggest any identification for John Eward Robinson or any of the Cooks, but John Edward's father *might* be John Henry Robinson, on 1881 census as John H Robinson, licensed victualler (of the Ordnance Arms Hotel, Hathersage, Derbyshire) aged 25, born Ashopton, Derbyshire, wife Hannah M (25, born Sheffield), child Charles H, 3, born Hathersage. This is the only John H(enry) Robinson I can find who was a publican in 1881. Charles Henry in FreeBMD born 1878, March Qtr., Bakewell 7b 742 (Bakewell district includes Hathersage) John Henry Robinson and Hannah Maria Dawson, marriage in FreeBMD 1877, June Qtr., Sheffield 9c 543. There are no John E(dward) Robinsons in the Bakewell district for 1881-2, and precious few anywhere else. HTH Kim Sargerson