Tim, I have a few Duttons from Columbus, in the time you are interested in. I have Marcia Dutton, daughter of John and Mary Ann Dutton, born in Ostelic NY, 1937 She married Octavius Dutton Fitch (peculiar middle name isn't it?) Lurancy Elizabeth Dutton (sister to Marcia Dutton) born 1839, Ostelic NY. Lurancy married Alexander Findley Leach. Sarah Dutton (another sister) born Columbus Pa, 1846. Married Robert Alexander. I have some more info from a paper written by Darwin Everett Leach in 1932. Most of these people are from either Columbus or Corry If any of these help, please let me know and I will forward anything else I have. Regards Rick