My foray into Otsego County is ending in disappointment, but maybe someone else can benefit. 1850 CENSUS, New York, Otsego County. Film 444296 Page 24, Exeter County, dwg 986. Esther Dutton age 46, female; with Smith Giles family, he age 44, wife Margaret 38. All born New York. Age on Esther looks like U6, so it is a guess. Page 80, Town of Edmeston, dwg 299 Alvin Dutton age 26 Farmer; Delilah age 29, Henry 14, Ruth 45. All born New York. Page 82, Town of Edmeston, dwg 330 Elen G. Dutton age 27, farmer; Mary D. age 24. Both born New York. Page 90, Town of Edmeston, dwg 461 Sophia Dutton age 51, Benjamin Dutton age 33 Farmer. Both born New York. Page 90, dwg 470 John dutton age 24, farmer; Julia A. age 24, ?Jereph A 3 (male) All born New York. The INDEX showed a Henry Dutton on page 41 in Richland. There was a Richfield on film 444296, but no Richland. Richland was not on film 444295 either. CNL on Henry. Richland must be on another film.