I have seen that one on the LDS site but it doesn't give a source. They also have them marrying in Grinton, Yorkshire on the same day, same year. I have been in touch with Yorkshire record office and they have no record of that marriage so I'm assuming it's the Newcastle one. Newcastle record office say that there are too many church records for them to look through and suggest I employ a researcher. I was hoping someone in Newcastle might help before I took that route. Thanks Glenys