Census 1851HO107/2403 folio 37 page 28 Whickham, Marley Hill Benjamin Robinson, Head, Mar, 66 Coal miner, Durham Lanchester Mary Robinson, Wife, Mar, 62, Durham Pensher [Penshaw] Isaac Robinson, Son, Unm, 25, Coal miner, Durham Houghton Le Spring Ann Robinson, Daur, Unm, 22, at Home, Durham Pensher Jane Robinson, Daur, Unm, 13, at Home, Durham Easington Thomas English, Lodger, unm, 28, Coal miner, Durham Whitworth Benjamin Robinson baptised 13 Nov 1786 son of Christopher Robinson. Lanchester All Saints This entry fits the age on the census. Isaac Robinson baptised 8 Oct 1826 Houghton Le Spring son of Benjamin Robinson and Mary. Ann Robinson baptised 21 Dec 1828 Penshaw All Saints daughter of Benjamin Robinson and Mary Smith. Living Shiney Row, occupation pitman. There are two others of this couple baptised in Penshaw: Joseph Robinson baptised 20 June 1827 son of Benjamin Robinson and Mary Smith of Shiney Row, Pitman George Robinson baptised 30 Sept 1832 son of Benjamin Robinson and Mary Smith of Shiney Row, Pitman Baptism of Jane Robinson in Easington St. Mary the Virgin 23 July 1837 daughter of Benjamin and Mary Marriage of Benjamin Robinson and Mary Smith in Houghton Le Spring 1 March 1823 I am not finding a good candidate for Mary Smith born/baptised Penshaw. Looking at the census you sited along with the children there it looks like Benjamin married the Mary Smith and not Mary Lee. Janis