OK, then it’s as I initially posited. FTDNA/Geno2 has erred in identifying me as CTS12173+, as I suspected. Mike On Apr 27, 2014, at 1:28 PM, Iain Kennedy <ikennedy_msdn2@hotmail.com> wrote: > No I didn't mention back mutations. As far as I can see every source (not counting FTDNA!) is in agreement that C is the ancestral value for CTS12173 and that is what I have in my old Geno file and my BAM file and so does everyone else I've looked at so far. For example Bob Degnen's BAM file shows a C at that position and that conflicts with his project display for the SNP that has him as derived. > > Name: CTS12173 Type: snp Source: point Position: ChrY:28505799..28505799 (+ strand) Length: 1 ISOGG_haplogroup: not listed YCC_haplogroup: not listed allele_anc: C allele_der: A > > Homo_sapiens > > chromosome:GRCh37:Y:28505799:28505799:1 > > > > Homo_sapiens 1 C 1 > VENTER 1 . 1 > WATSON 1 . 1 > > Degnen: > Total count: 16 > A : 0 > C : 16 (100%, 16+, 0- ) > G : 0 > T : 0 > N : 0 > --------------- > > project display: CTS12173+ > > > >

Could well be! On 4/27/2014 4:37 PM, Michael Farrell wrote: > OK, then it’s as I initially posited. FTDNA/Geno2 has erred in identifying me as CTS12173+, as I suspected. > > Mike > > On Apr 27, 2014, at 1:28 PM, Iain Kennedy <ikennedy_msdn2@hotmail.com> wrote: > >> No I didn't mention back mutations. As far as I can see every source (not counting FTDNA!) is in agreement that C is the ancestral value for CTS12173 and that is what I have in my old Geno file and my BAM file and so does everyone else I've looked at so far. For example Bob Degnen's BAM file shows a C at that position and that conflicts with his project display for the SNP that has him as derived. >> >> Name: CTS12173 Type: snp Source: point Position: ChrY:28505799..28505799 (+ strand) Length: 1 ISOGG_haplogroup: not listed YCC_haplogroup: not listed allele_anc: C allele_der: A >> >> Homo_sapiens > >> chromosome:GRCh37:Y:28505799:28505799:1 >> >> >> >> Homo_sapiens 1 C 1 >> VENTER 1 . 1 >> WATSON 1 . 1 >> >> Degnen: >> Total count: 16 >> A : 0 >> C : 16 (100%, 16+, 0- ) >> G : 0 >> T : 0 >> N : 0 >> --------------- >> >> project display: CTS12173+ >> >> >> >> > > > ------------------------------- > To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to DNA-R1B1C7-request@rootsweb.com with the word 'unsubscribe' without the quotes in the subject and the body of the message >