Barbra and all I have it down that there was a Joel Charles Dougherty born to Henry and his 2nd. wife Cynthia in Ind. in 1812 I have Lavina Dougherty b. 1817 m. John Dougherty {her cousin} Mary F. b. 1830, Maria 1835 these are on a census with Cynthina. I also have Cynthia Ann b. 1808, Isabelle 1808, Joseph 1816, John Jr. Mar. 29, 1819 d. 1886 m. Elizabeth Smith, Robert 1820, Jemima , Milton Thomas m. Mary Dougherty, and Patsy m. Michael Miller. I do not know if these are correct. Have found them in bits and peices as usual I am hopeing that there is one more a girl born around 1808 or so. Mary Lou