The James F. Cummins I have was born July 23, 1820 in Clark Co., Ohio. He married Anna E. Cahill on Sept. 24, 1861 in Logan Co., Ohio. James died Oct. 19,1877 in Ohio. Your James F. was born later. If your James was born in the Clark/Logan Co., Ohio area, could possibly be relative connection somewhere but would not be a son to my James. He had 3 daughters and one son, named Albert. Sorry I couldn't help you.