In a message dated 97-12-19 18:33:09 EST, you write: << I do not think our John Crew who md. Sarah Gatley had a prior wife. I think Catherine belonged to a different John Crew....possibly the one involved with the Pleasant woman. Anyway, due to his age at time of marriage to Sarah, I just can't quite accept that. >> above from Hazel to Chuck Pat & Hazel You both agree on this point. I'm deleting Catherine for the time being as I have no primary source. Chuck Demastus