Monica...okay, so I did one more search on 1920 census and appear to have found him also. 1920 census, Tulsa, Tulsa County, OK, p. 1A J.C. Cloud, age 46 or 48 or 43, born MO, parents born MO, works in boarding house Donald, son, age 12, born OK, parents born MO Rick, son, age 7, born OK, parents born MO So, I took another, closer , look at the 1910 census....The interpreter has him at age 53...it is very possible that it was 33..maybe top hook of first 3 did not show up so that it really does look like 53. But, 1920 census is pretty obvious that the first number in his age is a 4...the second number was intrepreted as a 6..but could possibly be an 8 or even a 3. The two numbers are very close together.