Information from the History of Carroll & Harrison Counties, Ohio, by Eckley & Perry 1921 pp 915 - 916 From a bio on Samuel A. Gunning: John Gunning father of Samuel A. was born in Franklin Twp. Harrison Co. Ohio and spent his life there as a general farmer and died August 14, 1901. He married Elizabeth Boyd, who was born in Coshocton Co. Ohio, and died May 11, 1919. Her parents were Samuel and Nancy Boyd, both of whom were born in Ireland, came early to Ohio and were members of the United Presbyterian Church. Mr & Mrs. Boyd had the following children: Samuel; Robert; William; Allen; David; Sarah; Agnes; Martha; Mary; Alice; and Elizabeth. John and Elizabeth Boyd Gunning had five children: Nancy Jane, d Oct 1911, wife of Simeon Rose; Samuel A. subject of sketch; Allen S.; Thomas W.; and Mattie Alice, wife of Frank Knisley. (this is not exactlly word for word but close enough) Hope this helps. Jane in Ohio