I have the marriage of Alice Reynolds to Joshua Caswell, Jr also. I was wondering if you have the parents of Joshua? I also don't have Alice as being the dtr of Electious & Charity. Can you tell me where you got that info from? I have (from Middleboro Vital Records to 1850) as their children: Jemima, Charity, Electious, Ezekiel, Sarah, Joel, Judah, Enos, Joshua I also have their dtr Charity Reynolds m. to Jotham Caswell (s/o Jotham Cas & Mary Reynolds) - Jotham is Charity's brother and Mary is Electious' sister. So you are correct they did marry into each other. This makes it even more confusing!! Nancy