I have a Julia Carroll who was born in Hudson, Columbia, NY. She married George Campbell of Tannersville, Greene, NY. They had 3 children, Frederick F. b. 26 Jan 1869, George F., b. 1870 and Gordon, b. 1874. Julia died 20 May 1875 and her body was returned to Hudson for burial. I was surprised by the references to Butler, NJ. Some of Frederick F. Campbell's children moved to NJ and some of the descendants now live in Butler.