I have found another history about John Carroll, b. 1826 or 1828, in Tn, and lived in the areas of, Carroll Co. Ar., Madison Co. Ar. and Vinita, Ok. IT. >From this written history it states that John Carroll came to IT with his father when he was around 10, this would be during the Trail of Tears when the Cherokee were removed from the East. He married Susan Ward, a Cherokee woman, and had two sons Hugh and Fincher. Susan Ward died in 1856, he then married Huldah Holcomb, Neosho, MO. This also states John was raised in Cherokee Nation, Hamilton, Meigs area Tn. So, if this history is in the least correct, Hugh Carroll m. Ann Shelton, father of JOhn Carroll was in the Cherokee Nation, Tn, when the removal started. Does anyone have any information of this Carroll family in this area? Thanks, Katy