There are three John Carpenters on the Tax Assessment List of Goshen, Orange County: 1. John Carpenter (blacksmith) District 10 2. John Carpenter (saddler) District 1 3. John Carpenter (stiller) District 7 Also on the list are Moses Carpenter, Ruth Carpenter, Increase Carpenter, and Moses Coe. Can the three Johns be identified as to spouse, etc? Was Ruth Carpenter the mother of any of them? I would appreciate answers to the identification of the three Johns. Margaret Cass