Phoebe, Joshua's wife was Sarah Burt, their son, Daniel Carpenter married Rebecca Dunn, and their son Benjamin C. Carpenter has a cousin Jane Dunn living with him in 1860 thru 1900 census. Eliza Dunn in 1860 census is possibly another cousin. I have no clue who the parents of these Dunn's were. Jane gives both parents born NY in 1880 and 1900 census. Dennis