Well Carpenter kin, I ask for your assistance again. If I can't trace back then I'll try going forward. I'm looking for the descendants of Robert Carpenter b. abt 1760 (of the Musketa Cove Carpenters). His sons were Abraham, Caleb, David, and Jacob. Did any of these boys have a son John b. abt 1803-4? They all ended up in Duanesburg(h) NY in Schenectady Co.. My GGG grandfather George Carpenter had a brother David b. abt 1825 who lived in Duanesburgh in the late 1840s to 1850s. It is supposed that Henry, David and George were all brothers and that John was their father. They all ended up residing in the town of Broome in Schoharie County NY. Different records have conflicting counties of birth for these 4. Thanks brethren.