I just found a new (to me) error in Carpenter Memorial. I think I've pieced together part of a resolution, but am hoping someone out there has the straight scoop to confirm it. All of the following pertains to Orange County NY: On p. 162 we have Jesse Carpenter #340, of Joseph 91, Samuel 27, John 17. Jesse is alleged to have 4 kids; Joseph, Jesse, Clarissa, Hannah. On p. 283 we find Jesse Carpenter #983, of Colvin 336, Joseph 91, Samuel 27, John 17. This Jesse is ALSO alleged to have 4 kids...named Clara, Joseph, Jesse, Hannah. One might be tempted to think Jesse 983 named his kids after his uncle Jesse 340. Alas, the coincidence becomes too too great, when we note that both sets of offspring seem to be born on the same dates and married to the same people. Separately, Coleman's "Early Records of the First Presbyterian Church At Goshen New York" cites (at p. 116) the 1791 baptism of Joseph, Clarissa, Jesse, and Hannah--all offspring of Jesse Carpenter. The 1791 date seems to confirm Jesse the father of these four kids as being Jesse #340 (b. about 1740, p. 88). The other Jesse (983) is said on p. 161 to be born 1778--a contemporary, not a parent, of the four baptees. If so, that leaves open who might be the spouse and children of Jesse 983. (Any info on this?) OK; Considering the Jesse #340 info, we then note that ABC has BOTH Clarissa and Hannah marrying a David Roe of Chester NY (with an "as reported" qualifier w/r Hannah). Does anyone have independent info on either of these young ladies' marriages? Robin C.