Do I remember someone in the past few days inquiring about Heiman Carpenter. I remembered that name and today he showed up in the Bradford Cty PA 1880 census for Smithfield Twp. Heiman is 49 and a Farmer b. PA Parents b. RI and VT wife: Harriet 47 years b. PA Parents born CT and RI William E. 21 b. Pa Parents born PA Frank E. 12 b. PA Parents born PA Also, separately, was listed a Phebe Carpenter age 51 a widow and housekeeper B. VT Father born Ireland and mother in CT. Hope this helps someone. Your loss, Mr. Smith. Indignation is quite different than rage. Audrey Annable Franklin