Sorry, hit the wrong button! LOL Sarah Carpenter b. abt 1824 married William Greenlee Edward Carpenter b. abt 1827, married Mary Arnold and died 23 Mar 1871 Sophia Carpenter b. abt 1828, married 1st James A. Copeland, 2nd William S. Bunyan I did find some other notes on Azor and Catherine. Azor died 6 May 1874 in Bement, IL. Catherine went to live with son, Charles Sylvester Bunyan in Pond Creek, OK then for the last three years with daughter, Eunice Emma Bunyan Brown in Bement, IL where she died 3 Sept 1907 at age 88. I would be happy to exchange information and compare documentation. I had not seen the migration pattern from Harrison County to Richland County and Ashland County, OH. That is a rather unusual track. Betsy McGee Rice Riceys5@aol.com