This is a Message Board Post that is gatewayed to this mailing list. Classification: Query Message Board URL: http://boards.ancestry.com/mbexec/msg/rw/WOC.2ACE/216.428.2.1 Message Board Post: Judy, Thanks so much for answering my query. My gr-grand parents were James Joseph and Jane (Chisholm) Hargrave. Her parents were Alexander and Catherine (Sinclair) Chisholm,from Antigonish. His parents were John and Mary (Livingstone) Chisholm. I've reached dead ends on Sinclairs and Livingstones and there are soooo many Chisholms! Betty