I believe the family lines have been crossed. I have found a Charles Campbell in Augusta Co., VA in the mid-1700’s involved in many land transactions. There was also a George Campbell in the county who appeared to be his son. However, these Campbells do not appear connected to George Campbell of Albermarle and Amherst counties who died in 1791. According to the oral history, Charles moved back to Ireland in 1724, where he died. The Charles Campbell of Augusta Co. died abt. 1768 and never returned to Europe. Hopefully another researcher can find and post further info about the George Campbells on the 1742 and 1744 passenger ships to the colonies in hope that we can identify one of them as George Campbell (d. 1791). Interestingly enough, there were 3 Catherine's on these ships as well (Catherine McClode, Duncan, and McDuff). I realize it was a common name, however, none of these three women were with anyone else with their last name, i.e. a father, brother, or husband. I would think it would be unusual for a woman to be travelling alone at the time, unless she was with her fiancee. So, it could be that one of these three women are Catherine "Caty" who married George. Two books which reappeared as sources in several articles on this subject, which may provide additional info: --"Ship Passenger Lists--The South (1538-1825)," edited by Carl Boyer --"Scots Banished to the American Plantations 1650- 1775," by David Dobson. I have not yet attempted to locate these books. If anyone does, please let us know what they contain.