Nancy Jane - Some things are clearing up and I'm not talking about sinuses! Thanks. John -----Original Message----- From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, April 21, 2004 10:53 AM To: [email protected]; [email protected] Subject: 1- Motley & Cagle's (not yours but may tie in) Hi This is not your group but this Motley family goes into the Cagle line also maybe will tie in with this family line. you never know. NancyJane (CA) Descendants of Captain John Motley Generation No. 1 1. Captain John1 Motley was born 1737, and died 1811. He married Elizabeth Page. She was born Abt. 1734, and died 1816. Children of Captain Motley and Elizabeth Page are: + 2 i. Sarah2 Motley, born 1765; died 1847. 3 ii. Catherine Elizabeth "Kate" Motley, born Abt. 1768. She married Nathan Johnson December 16, 1789. 4 iii. James Motley, born June 15, 1773; died April 26, 1838. He married Dicey Hipson January 11, 1802. + 5 iv. Edwin Motley. 6 v. Nancy Motley, born Abt. 1782. She married James Hardy Witherspoon January 17, 1805. 7 vi. Penelope "Penny" Motley, born 1783. She married Edward Lynn. 8 vii. Matthew Page Motley, born February 01, 1786; died September 17, 1843. He married Pheraby Norris September 20, 1816. Generation No. 2 2. Sarah2 Motley (Captain John1) was born 1765, and died 1847. She married Drury Smith October 03, 1786. He was born Abt. 1765, and died Bef. 1820. Children of Sarah Motley and Drury Smith are: + 9 i. Elizabeth3 Smith, born October 21, 1787 in , Moore, North Carolina; died August 06, 1866 in Carthage, Jasper, Missouri. + 10 ii. Frances M. Smith, born January 18, 1789 in , Montgomery, Noth Carolina; died April 12, 1872 in , Warren, Kentucy. 5. Edwin2 Motley (Captain John1) He married Martha "Patsy" Lynn. Children of Edwin Motley and Martha Lynn are: + 11 i. James "Squire"3 Motley, born April 16, 1808 in North Carolina; died September 18, 1877 in , Allen, Kentucky. + 12 ii. Edwin Lynn Motley, born May 06, 1806; died November 08, 1891 in , Warren, Kentucy. 13 iii. Anna Motley, born October 18, 1813; died March 31, 1894. She married John Armstrong Willougby October 18, 1831. Generation No. 3 9. Elizabeth3 Smith (Sarah2 Motley, Captain John1) was born October 21, 1787 in , Moore, North Carolina, and died August 06, 1866 in Carthage, Jasper, Missouri. She married Leonard Cagle 1802 in , Moore, North Carolina, son of John Cagle and Mary Unknown. He was born November 01, 1780 in , Moore, North Carolina, and died October 15, 1845 in Carthage, Jasper, Missouri. Notes for Elizabeth Smith: 1850 Census Jaspter County, Missouri Cagle, Elizabeth 62 NC No Occupation /$900 Illit. P. 390. (Along with her son Lindsey) Charles 27 KY Farmer Benjamin 24 " '' '' Sarah 22 " Willis 19 " Farmer n School Motley , Edwin L. 12 " " " (Elizabeth was the widow of Leonard Cagle of 1840 Allen County, KY. It is not known if Leonard died in KY. or in Mo. (Leonard was the son of John Cagel of Davidson County, Tennessee.) Parents of Elizabeth Smith Father Drury Smith Mother Sarah "Sally " Motley Children : Susanneh Cagle December 30, 1811 Married February 25, 1834./ October 06, 1834. Spouse was James "Squire " Motley This information on Elizabeth's parents and one child are from WRT. vol 5, Tree 3042. Notes for Leonard Cagle: 1810 , Warren, Kentucky Cagle , Leonard 2001 1 001 P.280 1820 & 1830 , Allen, Kentucky Cagle, Leonared 21101 - 1011001 P. 071 1840 , Allen, Kentucky Cagle, Leonard 110210001 - 00101001 1840s & 1850s His widow and family appeared in the census of Jasper County, Missouri . (page 718 Missouri, Jasper County, ) Leonard Cagle Family Bible (Jasper county, Missouri) All information is right from the Family Bible of Leonard Cagel 1780-1845. This should help clarify the family relation ships amoung the Cagle's of Jasper & Lawrence County, Missouri. (information was form Mr. Robert Ernest Cagle of California) . Some of his notes about the children : One of the sons listed, Linsey settled in Lawrence County,Missouri. Henry was in California in 1850 and 1860. Robert died as a infant. Edwin stayed in Jasper County, Missouri. David remained in Jasper County, Missouri. Benjamin who died in 1900 moved to Chariton County, Missouri. Willis moved to Saline County, Missouri. Rebecca 1817-1884 married John Logan Schooling on January 29, 1846 and their daughter, Barthena Schooling, later married to David C. Cagel born 1843, who was the son of Lindsey Cagel ,1807-1843, on July 20, 1865. Other Jasper County, Marriages were David Cagle 1820-1896 to Mary J. Jaselwood, November 29, 1854, and Benjamin Cagle 1825-1900, to Martha Walton on September 23, 1860 Information is from John G. Cagles book , Cagle records of the South 1860 to 1910. Children of Elizabeth Smith and Leonard Cagle are: 14 i. Leonard4 Cagle, born April 14, 1804 in , Cabarrus, North Carolina. + 15 ii. Lindsey Cagle, born May 19, 1807 in , Allen, Kentucky; died December 02, 1863 in , Lawrence, Missouri. 16 iii. Henry Cagle, born December 16, 1809 in , Allen, Kentucky; died in California. He married Martha Hewlett October 11, 1856 in , Lawrence, Missouri. Notes for Henry Cagle: Cagle, Henry to Hewlett, Martha, on October 11. 1856 by Reuben Woods, J.P. + 17 iv. Susanneh Cagle, born December 30, 1811 in , Allen, Kentucky; died October 06, 1836 in , Allen, Kentucky. 18 v. Robert Cagle, born December 14, 1813 in , Allen, Kentucky; died August 25, 1814 in , Allen, Kentucky. + 19 vi. Edwin Cagle, born July 11, 1815 in , Allen, Kentucky; died August 20, 1864 in , Jasper, Missouri. + 20 vii. Rebecca Cagle, born November 28, 1818 in , Allen, Kentucky; died September 15, 1884 in , Jasper, Missouri. + 21 viii. David F. Cagle, born January 28, 1820 in , Allen, Kentucky; died March 1896 in , Jasper, Missouri. 22 ix. Charles Cagle, born April 09, 1823 in , Allen, Kentucky; died February 14, 1867 in , Jasper, Missouri. + 23 x. Benjamin Franklin Cagle, born July 31, 1825 in , Allen, Kentucky; died 1900 in Bee Branch, Chariton, Missouri. 24 xi. Sarah Cagle, born February 25, 1828 in , Allen, Kentucky. + 25 xii. Willis Cagle, born October 16, 1830 in , Randolph, North Carolina; died April 14, 1879 in , Saline, Missouri. 10. Frances M.3 Smith (Sarah2 Motley, Captain John1) was born January 18, 1789 in , Montgomery, Noth Carolina, and died April 12, 1872 in , Warren, Kentucy. She married Sampson Cagle August 09, 1804 in , Montgomery, North Carolina, son of John Cagle and Mary Unknown. He was born June 08, 1783 in , Moore, North Carolina, and died January 17, 1874 in , Warren, Kentucy. Notes for Frances M. Smith: Notes for Sampson Cagle: Ancestral File #( AFT:TFHH-J4) Notes : Sampson Cagle, 1782 - 1874. A native of Sanly /Cabarrus area of North Carolina, is belived to be the son of John Cagle Sr. ca1740 -1826, who moved from North Carolina to Davidson County, Tennessee, about 1800. Sampson with his older brother Leonard, 1780 -1845, moved to Warren County, Kentucky. Between 1800 and 1810, and appeard in the 1810 Warren County, Kentucky,. In the 1840 Leonard moved ot Jasper County, Missour, but Sampson remained in Kenrucky until his death. for a part of his time in Kentucky. Sampson lived in Allen County, which adjoins Warren County,. The 1830 census of Warren County, shows Sampson with 1 son and 6 daughters; later census of Warren County, and his sons name is unknown. Susan and Frances, daughters of Sampson listed in 1860 census were unmarried, and are buried near their parents in the family cemetery. On the Sampson Cagle homeplace, near Hunt's Bend River in Warren County, Kentucky. 1810 , Allen, Kentucky Cagle, Sampson 001 - 201 P.280 1820 , Allen, Kentucky Cagle, Sampson P.120 (1830 Warren County, Kentucky (Allen was formaed in 1815 form Warren and Barren co's) 1830 Warren, Kentucky Cagle, Sampson 0100001 - 1031201 P.109 1840 , Warren, Kentucky (Nothing ) 1850 , Warren, Kentucky Cagle , Sampson 67 NC. Farmer R/$1000 P.067; 2nd. Dist. Frances 61 NC Illiterate Susan 29 KY Frances 25 " D_______Ann 19 " 1860 , Warren Kentucky : Dist. #1, Bowling Green P.O. Cagle, Sampson 77 NC Farmer /$582/$956 Frances 72 " Wife Susan 42 KY Daughter Frances 38 " '' '' 1870 , Warren, Kentucky Lucus Precinct., Bristow P.O. Cagle , Sampson 87 NC Farmer/$3000/$6000 Fanny F. 84 '' Housekeeping Susan 57 KY At Home /0/$250 Fanny 45 '' "" "" /0/$300 1880 Warren County, Kentucky, Bristow Precinct Cagle, Frances 53 KY NC NC Housekeeping Susy 63 '' " " The census taker notes that both Frances and Susy where born in Allen County, Ky. Samson 1782-1874, remained permanently in the Warren County/Allen County,, area and is buried at the Cagle Family Cemetery in Warren County, More About Sampson Cagle: Census: 1810, , Allen, Kentucky Children of Frances Smith and Sampson Cagle are: + 26 i. Rebecca4 Cagle, born September 29, 1808 in , Allen, Kentucy; died September 11, 1871 in , Warren, Kentucy. 27 ii. Mary Cagle, born June 08, 1811 in , Allen, Kentucy; died January 29, 1875. She married John Motley 1838 in , Warren, Kentucy; born January 05, 1811 in , Warren, Kentucy; died November 30, 1878. 28 iii. Susan Cagle, born March 03, 1818 in , Allen, Kentucy; died February 06, 1882 in , Warren, Kentucky. Notes for Susan Cagle: 1850 , Warren, Kentucky Cagle , Sampson 67 NC. Farmer R/$1000 P.067; 2nd. Dist. Frances 61 NC Illiterate Susan 29 KY Frances 25 " D_______Ann 19 " 1860 , Warren Kentucky : Dist. #1, Bowling Green P.O. Cagle, Sampson 77 NC Farmer /$582/$956 Frances 72 " Wife Susan 42 KY Daughter Frances 38 " '' '' 1870 , Warren, Kentucky Lucus Precinct., Bristow P.O. Cagle , Sampson 87 NC Farmer/$3000/$6000 Fanny F. 84 '' Housekeeping Susan 57 KY At Home /0/$250 Fanny 45 '' "" "" /0/$300 1880 Warren County, Kentucky, Bristow Precinct Cagle, Frances 53 KY NC NC Housekeeping Susy 63 '' " " Notes: Susan was unmarried and is buried on Sampson Cagle homeplace, Near Hunt's Bend of the Barren River in Warren County, Kentucky. Susan was buried under the name Motley, she could have been married late in life. Buried next to her sister Rebecca Motley and her parents Sampson Cagle and wife Frances Smith Cagle. Buried on the Sampson homeplace. Cagle Cemetery. 29 iv. Frances Cagle, born October 09, 1829 in , Allen, Kentucy; died 1872 in , Warren, Kentucky. Notes for Frances Cagle: 1850 , Warren, Kentucky Cagle , Sampson 67 NC. Farmer R/$1000 P.067; 2nd. Dist. Frances 61 NC Illiterate Susan 29 KY Frances 25 " D_______Ann 19 " 1860 , Warren Kentucky : Dist. #1, Bowling Green P.O. Cagle, Sampson 77 NC Farmer /$582/$956 Frances 72 " Wife Susan 42 KY Daughter Frances 38 " '' '' 1870 , Warren, Kentucky Lucus Precinct., Bristow P.O. Cagle , Sampson 87 NC Farmer/$3000/$6000 Fanny F. 84 '' Housekeeping Susan 57 KY At Home /0/$250 Fanny 45 '' "" "" /0/$300 1880 Warren County, Kentucky, Bristow Precinct Cagle, Frances 53 KY NC NC Housekeeping Susy 63 '' " " Notes: Frances was unmarried, and is buried next to her parents on the Sampson Cagle homeplace, near Hunt's Bend ot the Barren river in Warren County, Kentucky . 11. James "Squire"3 Motley (Edwin2, Captain John1) was born April 16, 1808 in North Carolina, and died September 18, 1877 in , Allen, Kentucky. He married Susanneh Cagle February 25, 1834 in , Allen, Kentucky, daughter of Leonard Cagle and Elizabeth Smith. She was born December 30, 1811 in , Allen, Kentucky, and died October 06, 1836 in , Allen, Kentucky. Children of James Motley and Susanneh Cagle are: 30 i. Sally4 Motley, born May 15, 1831; died August 28, 1912. She married William Witherspoon Willoughby. 31 ii. Edwin Cagle Motley, born May 23, 1835; died September 13, 1915. He married Elizabeth Landers March 28, 1858. 12. Edwin Lynn3 Motley (Edwin2, Captain John1) was born May 06, 1806, and died November 08, 1891 in , Warren, Kentucy. He married Rebecca Cagle March 29, 1825 in , Warren, Kentucy, daughter of Sampson Cagle and Frances Smith. She was born September 29, 1808 in , Allen, Kentucy, and died September 11, 1871 in , Warren, Kentucy. Child of Edwin Motley and Rebecca Cagle is: 32 i. Mary Jane4 Motley, born October 09, 1834 in , Warren, Kentucy; died July 01, 1915. She married Thomas Perry Buchanan June 04, 1854. Generation No. 4 15. Lindsey4 Cagle (Elizabeth3 Smith, Sarah2 Motley, Captain John1) was born May 19, 1807 in , Allen, Kentucky, and died December 02, 1863 in , Lawrence, Missouri. He married Mahulda Pruitt October 11, 1834 in Allen, Kentucky. She was born May 23, 1816 in , , Kentucky, and died December 23, 1893 in , , Missouri. Notes for Lindsey Cagle: 1840 Allen County, Kentucky Cagle , Lindsey 000001 - 20001 P. 071 1850 Jasper County, Missouri Cagle, Linsey 43 NC Farmer Illiterate P.390 Mahala 34 KY Susannah 10 " In School David 6 " Malinda 12 " In School Leonard 3 " Alfred 1 " 1860 Census Lawrence County, Missouri Mt. Pleasant Township Cagle,, Lindsey 53 NC FARMER Huldey 44 KY David 17 " Leonard 15 " WERE AT IN THE CENSUS 1840 Allen County, KY. 1850 Jasper County, , Mo. 1860 Llawrence County, Mo. 1870 Lawrence County, Mo. (Mahulda was a widow) Children of Lindsey Cagle and Mahulda Pruitt are: 33 i. David C.5 Cagle, born September 1843 in , , Kentucky; died February 19, 1922 in Mt. Pleasant, Lawrence, Missouri. He married Barthena Schooling July 20, 1865 in , Lawrence, Missouri; born November 1844 in , , Missouri; died February 24, 1917 in Mt. Pleasant, Lawrence, Missouri. Notes for David C. Cagle: Notes in John G. Cagle's book . Cagle Census records of the South, 1860 TO 1910 . Page 710, 1870 Lawrence , MO. Mt. Pleasant Township There is a photo of David Cagle 1843-1919 on this page . David s/o Linday and Mahulda Cagle , enlisted in the Union Army on November 01, 1863, and served in Company C., 15 Regiment MO. Cavalry Volunteers. Before being discharged on November 01, 1865, He served as a cook in the Army and also fought engagements, including the defense of the Mo. State Capitol during the confederate General Price's 2nd raid. His closest brush with death came in a skirmish near Sarcoxie , Jasper county, Missouri. Described as follows by a fellow soldier S. M. Brown (Jasper County in the Civil War PP.185-86) When we advanced on them it was the writer's misfortune to right in advance with John White , Davy Cagle and Huestin Beck , The fence on our South , the fence and the Bushwhackers on our North . Humbard (The Confederate Officer ) fired and called to his men to "come out and five them hell" . Humbard's shot killed John White who fell across my horse right in front of me. Such a rain of bullets and shots went over and around out heads , I had never heard before of since. We only lost one man. 1870 Lawrence, Mo. Mt. Pleasant Township: #79/78 Cagle, David 26 KY Farmer Barthena 25 MO. Keepinghouse (Barthena , mother was a Cagle,) (1st cousin.) William F. 4 " Lenora F. 2 " Linda R. 4/12 MO. Notes: Barthena parents were Rebecca Cagle who married to John Logan Schooling. Rebecca was the sister of Lindsey Cagle who was married to Mahulda Pruitt, and where the parents of David C. Cagle ( David C. Cagle and Barthena Schooling were first cousins). 1880 Lawrence MO. Mt. Pleasant Township #401/406 Cagle, David 36 KY KY KY Farmer Barthena 36 MO KY SC Keeping House /"sick with chills" William 13 MO KY MO At School Lenora F. 12 " " " " " " Melinda B. 10 " " " " ' ' Lulie A. 7 " " " " " " Charles W. 4 " " " " " 1900 Census , Lawrence, Mo, Mt. Pleasant Township Cagle, David 56 KY Sep. 1843 s/o Lindsey Cagle 55 78 Barthena 55 MO Nov. 1844 4 75 Jesse E. 10 " Apr. 1890 1910 Census Lawrence, MO. Mt. Pleasant Township Cagle, David 66 KY (s/o Lindsey Cagle , Barthenia Cagle is Bartenia ) 59 94 Thenia 65 MO Irl 20 MO David and his brother and there familys lived permanently in Mt. Pleasnt Township of Lawrence Co. MO. David died on Feb. 09, 1822, at the age of 78. His wife, Barthena Schooling Cagle. His wife , Barthena Schooling Cagle , preceded him in death on Feb. 24, 1917, . At the age of 72. Both are Buried at the Mr. Olivet Church Cemetery, Mr. Pleasant township. David obituary in the Peice city , Leader- Journal, listed surviving Children as Wm. F. Cagle, Charles W. Cagle, Earl Cagle , Mrs Lenora Goodman and Lula Boucher, an Susie Anderson . Buried near by his son Earl whos stone reads: "Jesse Earl Cagle 1890-1947"