Carole, Actually, I never made the determination. John G Cagle of Arkansas published several books and Journals. I went through these for over two years assembling all his information on the CAGLEs prior to 1850 into some order I could understand. Much of his information is scattered in different reference books, but in this way I combined land records, biblical records, census records, wills, surveys, etc. John G did most of the research from the old courthouses. I have been working on the Cagles of Leonhart for the past 10 years, averaging over 70 hours per week. There is very little that can be proven absolutely on the older generations. My primary work now is transcribing census records from 1850 to 1930 and attempting to identify them all. It is probably more than I can finish. I am 70 years old, had four heart attacks, and installed a pacemaker/defibrulator after my heartbeats dropped to 24 per minute. This was only a couple of years ago, but I was back at it within a week. I have still not finished with going through all of John's work which I plan to start back with as soon as I finish with the census records. John's great grandfather and mine were brothers, but he still charged me the same price as he did everyone else for his various works. Good luck with your research. I would look all these up for you, but there are just too many sources to check and would be too time consuming. And, as I said, I do not have his complete volumns. Check with David of Tennessee, I believe he has even more of John's work than I and might even have the time or answers. Lee Cagle Okla City -- "Carole Cook" <carolescoaching@mstarmetro.net> wrote: Lee, I have seen your information on Ancestry World Tree Project: Cagle-Carter-Jackson-James-Jinks-Archer Genealogy Database on Ancestry.com. Please share with me how you determined that John Cagle #23, who married Lucy, was the son of Karl Wilhelm Cagle #5 rather than the son of Charles Cagle #7. I would also like to know how you determined that John Francis Cagle #41 was the son of Charles Cagle #7. Carole Cook ------------------------------- To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to CAGLE-request@rootsweb.com with the word 'unsubscribe' without the quotes in the subject and the body of the message _____________________________________________________________ Click to get freedom from your annoying glasses. Save on LASIK surgery. http://track.juno.com/s/lc?u=http://tagline.untd.us/fc/Ioyw6iifdpLkLq2TSJ8XNcEmg1bTbhVhUXn0PZlWx8EFRmKWpVVkN7/

Lee, Thanks for your reply. Is John G. Cagle still living? Carole Cook -----Original Message----- From: cagle-bounces@rootsweb.com [mailto:cagle-bounces@rootsweb.com] On Behalf Of Lee Cagle Sent: Sunday, June 24, 2007 9:03 PM To: cagle@rootsweb.com Subject: Re: [CAGLE] Question for Lee Cagle Carole, Actually, I never made the determination. John G Cagle of Arkansas published several books and Journals. I went through these for over two years assembling all his information on the CAGLEs prior to 1850 into some order I could understand. Much of his information is scattered in different reference books, but in this way I combined land records, biblical records, census records, wills, surveys, etc. John G did most of the research from the old courthouses. I have been working on the Cagles of Leonhart for the past 10 years, averaging over 70 hours per week. There is very little that can be proven absolutely on the older generations. My primary work now is transcribing census records from 1850 to 1930 and attempting to identify them all. It is probably more than I can finish. I am 70 years old, had four heart attacks, and installed a pacemaker/defibrulator after my heartbeats dropped to 24 per minute. This was only a couple of years ago, but I was back at it within a week. I have still not finished with going through all of John's work which I plan to start back with as soon as I finish with the census records. John's great grandfather and mine were brothers, but he still charged me the same price as he did everyone else for his various works. Good luck with your research. I would look all these up for you, but there are just too many sources to check and would be too time consuming. And, as I said, I do not have his complete volumns. Check with David of Tennessee, I believe he has even more of John's work than I and might even have the time or answers. Lee Cagle Okla City -- "Carole Cook" <carolescoaching@mstarmetro.net> wrote: Lee, I have seen your information on Ancestry World Tree Project: Cagle-Carter-Jackson-James-Jinks-Archer Genealogy Database on Ancestry.com. Please share with me how you determined that John Cagle #23, who married Lucy, was the son of Karl Wilhelm Cagle #5 rather than the son of Charles Cagle #7. I would also like to know how you determined that John Francis Cagle #41 was the son of Charles Cagle #7. Carole Cook